Your agent said no to an offer. Did they ask you first?

Your agent said no to an offer. Did they ask you first?

The buyers were keen. The offer never reached the seller.

Last week a buyer of ours almost lost an offer on his own home. The buyers had viewed it, they were keen, they wanted to talk numbers. But his agent told them it wouldn’t be enough, so they never put the offer in. He only found out by chance.

He’s buying one of our homes and selling his own to do it, so he needs offers on the table to move. When he heard what had happened, he had to tell his own agent to go back, encourage the offer, and bring it to him to decide.

He got his offer. But only because he stepped in to rescue one that was never meant to reach him.

The job is to find your buyer, not guard a number

You name a figure, and it’s easy to treat it as a line to defend. But a defended number only tells you a buyer walked away. It doesn’t tell you what they’d have paid, and only one of those helps you decide.

The rules make agents pass on offers. They don’t stop offers being killed first.

The Property Ombudsman’s Code of Practice requires an agent to tell you about every offer up to exchange, and confirm it in writing within two working days. The only exception is an offer you’ve said, in writing, not to pass on.

But a conversation that talks a buyer out of offering never becomes an offer. Nothing gets written down, nothing gets recorded, and you never know it happened. That’s the version no rule catches.

What an unmade offer costs you

If you’re in a chain, it’s simple:

No offer means no proceedable position on the home you actually want

The buyers who were turned away book viewings somewhere else

You never find out what someone would have paid

An offer under what you want isn’t a waste of your time. Sometimes it opens the negotiation. Sometimes it shows you where the market really is. Sometimes it moves your own position, because now there’s a real buyer to weigh against your onward purchase. None of that can happen if the offer never arrives.

We've Been That Agent

We haven’t always got this right. In June we wrote about a buyer we discouraged from offering in 2023 (We got this one wrong). It cost the seller a buyer, and it's why we changed how we handle offers.

So here’s how we work now. Every offer goes to our sellers, including the ones we expect them to turn down. You decide, not us. Our job is to bring you what the market is offering, not to pick for you what you’re allowed to hear.

Let Them Offer

You can still turn down anything that comes in. That's your right as the seller.

But give yourself the chance to turn it down. An offer you reject is still an option you had. One that never gets made leaves you with none.

If you're the buyer: put your offer in writing anyway. An email is enough. Under the Code, the agent has to pass it on and confirm it in writing within two working days, unless the seller has told them in writing not to pass on offers like yours. If that's the reason, you're entitled to ask.

See It Before It's Listed

The next homes we're launching are on our coming soon page now. Before they reach the portals, a small number of registered buyers can view them, and make an offer if they want to.

Two flats in KT2 and a four bedroom semi-detached house in KT5. There's no price and no address on the page. You register, we check the home suits what you're looking for, then we book your viewing and send the address.

Every offer that comes from those viewings goes to the seller.

We film the conversations sellers don't usually hear, from the buyer's side of the table. Watch them on YouTube.

If you know someone selling in order to buy, forward this to them before their next viewing.

Want to see what's happening on your road? Reply with your postcode and we'll send you the neighbourhood market diagnostic: everything listed, sold, reduced and withdrawn within a quarter mile over the last twelve months.

Warm regards,

Alex